George Clooney pens letter over SAG talks
Actor takes neutral position, outlines 'fundamental facts'
If SAG and AFTRA were warring countries, then George Clooney would be Switzerland.
The actor on Thursday released a two-page message that gives a neutral position, laying out both sides of the fighting union's positions and focusing on the issues of the working actor.
"Both are, of course right," Clooney wrote. "AFTRA feels that a work stoppage would be devastating to its members and SAG believes that if they don't draw a line in the sand, the studios will repeat what they did with DVDs."
Clooney's statement is the first detailed one he has released since the talks began and since he and several other high-profile union members took out ads shortly after the WGA strike ended, urging SAG and AFTRA to "just talk" with the studios and start talks early. He had earlier released a statement denying a rumor that he was supporting the anti-AFTRA campaign.
AFTRA had no comment on the statement, and SAG could not immediately be reached for comment.
AFTRA brokered its tentative contract with the Alliance of Motion Picture & Television Producers on May 28 without SAG for the first time in 27 years, after suspending its joint-bargaining agreement with the sister union.
Since then, SAG has waged a campaign to get its dual cardholder members, which sit at about 44,000, to vote down the AFTRA contract.
SAG claims that voting down the AFTRA contract does not mean there will be a strike, but rather it will get its sister union back to the negotiating table.
But labor experts and industry insiders don't believe that AFTRA will return to the bargaining table if the contract is voted down given the animosity generated from the SAG campaign. Rather, they will most likely return alone and renegotiated the contract.
Over the past week, several A-list actors have taken sides in the debate over whether AFTRA's newly brokered primetime/TV contract should be ratified or voted down.
Tom Hanks, Kevin Spacey, Sally Field and Alec Baldwin are among the dual cardholders (those who are both SAG and AFTRA members) who support the new AFTRA contract.
Jack Nicholson, Ben Stiller, Martin Sheen and Viggo Mortensen are among the high-profile actors who support SAG's position of voting down the contract.
In his statement, Clooney laid out some "fundamental facts" that both sides need to begin with, including that the DGA, WGA and IATSE have already set the contract model, minus DVD residuals, and that breaking that model would "retroactively break the other models."
Clooney also took a page from SAG's national executive director Doug Allen's NFL playbook, stating that the chief negotiator "has said on several occasions that this would be a negotiation for 'the lineman, not for the quarterbacks.' "
"The spirit of the statement isn't wrong, it's just the structure," Clooney wrote. "Unlike the NFL, in this guild, the quarterbacks protect the linemen. I've been very lucky in my career, which has put me in the place that I don't need a union to check on my residuals, or my pension, or protect my 12-hour turnaround. I used to need that, and may again, but right now I don't.
"That means it's my responsibility to look out for actors who are trying to stay afloat from year-to-year," he added. "Anything less is irresponsible of me."
Clooney concluded his statement with a suggestion for the future: creating a 10-member panel of influential A-listers such as Nicholson and Hanks to sit down with studio heads once a year -- "10 people that the studio heads don't often say 'no' to" -- who can bring in SAG and AFTRA data and adjust pay for the actors.
He also suggested that the unions raise the dues for actors who make "an exorbitant amount of money."
"Right now, there's a cap of 6,000 bucks that actors pay their union, based on $1 million dollars in earnings," he wrote. "Make it $6,000 for every million. If someone makes $20 million, they pay $120,000 into the union. That could go a long way in helping pensions and health care. The quarterbacks have to do more."
Clooney's full letter appears on the next page.
Clooney's full letter follows:
At the risk of being yet another actor giving his opinion about the ongoing fight between SAG and AFTRA, I'm hoping that there might be a way out of this. Rather than pitting artist against artist, maybe we could find a way to get what both unions are looking for.
Both are, of course, right. AFTRA feels that a work stoppage would be devastating to its members and SAG believes that if they don't draw a line in the sand, the studios will repeat what they did with DVDs.
There are a couple of fundamental facts that both sides have to start with ... first is that the WGA, DGA and IATSE all agreed to a certain model (DVDs not being a part of it). Breaking that model for AFTRA or SAG would retroactively break the other models ... so you can be pretty sure that the AMPTP isn't going to do that. The second thing is understanding the way these unions work. They're unique in structure to other unions. Doug Allen (the SAG national executive director) has said on several occasions that this would be a negotiation for "the linemen, not for the quarterbacks." (Doug did a lot of the negotiating for the NFL.) The spirit of the statement isn't wrong ... it's just the structure. Unlike the NFL, in this guild, the quarterbacks protect the linemen. I've been very lucky in my career, which has put me in the place that I don't need a union to check on my residuals, or my pension, or protect my 12-hour turnaround. I used to need that, and may again ... but right now I don't. That means it's my responsibility to look out for actors who are trying to stay afloat from year to year. Anything less is irresponsible of me.
Work stoppage will do a great deal of harm to those actors ... agencies will close ... TV pilots won't get made ... more reality shows ... we all know the scenario. But that doesn't mean just roll over and give the producers what they want ... it means diligence.
The producers say that there's no money in new media right now. There's some truth in that ... for this moment. It was also true for cable, VHS and DVD ... all of which became very profitable for the studios ... and the actors were out in the cold. With new media, we have our foot in the door, but who's to say a year from now, if it becomes profitable, that the same thing won't happen again ... actors out in the cold. So here are a couple of ways that the quarterbacks can protect the linemen:
First, we set up a panel ... Jack Nicholson and Tom Hanks, for instance ... 10 of them that sit down with the studio heads once a year ... 10 people that the studio heads don't often say "no" to. Those 10 people walk in the door with all the new data that SAG and AFTRA compile, and adjust the pay for actors... once a year.
Second, we go to the actors who make an exorbitant amount of money, and raise their dues. Right now, there's a cap of 6,000 bucks that actors pay their union ... based on $1 million in earnings. Make it $6,000 for every million ... if someone makes $20 million, they pay $120,000 into the union. That could go a long way in helping pensions and health care. The quarterbacks have to do more.
To be sure, I'm not the brightest bulb out there. So maybe someone has a lot better idea ... I just happen to believe so strongly in both unions ... my father, my mother, aunt, uncle, even cousins were all members of either SAG or AFTRA long before me.
What we can't do is pit artist against artist ... because the one thing you can be sure of is that stories about Jack Nicholson vs. Tom Hanks only strengthens the negotiating power of the AMPTP.
George Clooney
See Also
posted by atiedesandy @ 21:05
<< Home